THE GLOWING ORACLE | SHOW US THE BILL — COMMUNITY WORKSHEET
A data-center proposal usually arrives with a price tag for the developer. The community needs a different figure: the value it actually receives, the costs it actually bears, and the risks it inherits. This evidence checklist gives residents, journalists, planning boards, utilities and elected officials a practical way to ask for the same records.
Use this for one named facility or project. Fill in its operator, street or permitted parcel, utility and water service area, legal agreements, dates, and project phases. A statewide statistic is useful background but is not a substitute for a facility-specific answer.
Printable worksheet: Download Show Us the Bill — Six-Page Community Scorecard (PDF). Use it to record the original evidence, payer, reporting year and unanswered questions for a named facility. The PDF is a blank investigation worksheet, not an assessment or rating of any operator.
The community record
- Facility name and operator: ______
- Physical parcel or address, county, state/country: ______
- Proposal or operating phase, maximum approved power capacity (MW): ______
- Utility and regulator docket or tariff reference: ______
- Water supplier, aquifer/river/catchment and permits: ______
- Review date, reporting period and independent reviewer: ______
Fourteen questions to ask before approving a data center
1. Grid connection and peak load
Approved maximum MW, meter-tested peak MW, annual MWh, expected ramp-up dates; cite utility interconnection order.
Evidence status: Not documented / Requested / Partial / Supported / Disputed / Not applicable. Original record: ______. Reporting year and location: ______. Who pays or benefits? ______.
2. Cost of grid upgrades
Line/substation cost, developer contribution, customer tariff recovery, bonds and stranded-capacity commitments.
Evidence status: Not documented / Requested / Partial / Supported / Disputed / Not applicable. Original record: ______. Reporting year and location: ______. Who pays or benefits? ______.
3. Verified demand response
Contracted curtailment versus metered event MW, duration, rebound MWh and operator confirmation.
Evidence status: Not documented / Requested / Partial / Supported / Disputed / Not applicable. Original record: ______. Reporting year and location: ______. Who pays or benefits? ______.
4. Where the water comes from
Local utility, watershed/aquifer, permitted potable and reclaimed volumes, alternative drought sources.
Evidence status: Not documented / Requested / Partial / Supported / Disputed / Not applicable. Original record: ______. Reporting year and location: ______. Who pays or benefits? ______.
5. Water balance
Withdrawn, consumed, discharged, reused m³/year and peak summer demands; do not confuse WUE with local scarcity.
Evidence status: Not documented / Requested / Partial / Supported / Disputed / Not applicable. Original record: ______. Reporting year and location: ______. Who pays or benefits? ______.
6. Taxes actually received
Separate city, county, state and schools; year-by-year audited amounts, not project announcements.
Evidence status: Not documented / Requested / Partial / Supported / Disputed / Not applicable. Original record: ______. Reporting year and location: ______. Who pays or benefits? ______.
7. Tax exemptions and incentives
Property abatements, sales-tax exemptions, grants, public bonds, and their sponsors and sunset dates.
Evidence status: Not documented / Requested / Partial / Supported / Disputed / Not applicable. Original record: ______. Reporting year and location: ______. Who pays or benefits? ______.
8. Construction and permanent jobs
Full-time equivalent and worker-years, contractors, local resident hires, salaries and training records.
Evidence status: Not documented / Requested / Partial / Supported / Disputed / Not applicable. Original record: ______. Reporting year and location: ______. Who pays or benefits? ______.
9. Public services
Fire response, inspections, road maintenance, diesel permit enforcement and documented new operating costs.
Evidence status: Not documented / Requested / Partial / Supported / Disputed / Not applicable. Original record: ______. Reporting year and location: ______. Who pays or benefits? ______.
10. Land and opportunity costs
Previous land use, assessed values, alternative housing, agriculture or conservation use, impact on nearby property.
Evidence status: Not documented / Requested / Partial / Supported / Disputed / Not applicable. Original record: ______. Reporting year and location: ______. Who pays or benefits? ______.
11. Noise, air, and thermal impacts
Noise studies, generator emissions, water-discharge temperature, permits, monitoring results and complaints.
Evidence status: Not documented / Requested / Partial / Supported / Disputed / Not applicable. Original record: ______. Reporting year and location: ______. Who pays or benefits? ______.
12. Fiber and communications
Who funds new telecom runs, road work and ongoing maintenance, and whether residents gain any benefit.
Evidence status: Not documented / Requested / Partial / Supported / Disputed / Not applicable. Original record: ______. Reporting year and location: ______. Who pays or benefits? ______.
13. Enforceable benefits
Signed community-benefit payments, district heat actually delivered, workforce commitments and independent auditing.
Evidence status: Not documented / Requested / Partial / Supported / Disputed / Not applicable. Original record: ______. Reporting year and location: ______. Who pays or benefits? ______.
14. What happens if the project fails?
Minimum utility payments, performance guarantees, remediation funds, abandonment/decommissioning and stranded asset liability.
Evidence status: Not documented / Requested / Partial / Supported / Disputed / Not applicable. Original record: ______. Reporting year and location: ______. Who pays or benefits? ______.
How to read the results
Use a documented-answers count, not a greenwashing score. A blank entry means evidence is missing—not that cost is zero, not that a developer is hiding something, and not that the project fails automatically. ‘Supported’ requires an original source that actually answers the specific question for the defined facility and reporting period.
Keep four ledgers distinct: (1) public money and taxes; (2) electricity and water system impacts; (3) employment and enforceable benefits; and (4) unpriced environmental or social effects. Do not combine different payers, tax jurisdictions or years as though they were the same budget.
A simple community fiscal model
Potential annual fiscal balance = documented local taxes and fees received + enforceable annual cash benefit payments − documented local incentives and abatements − incremental municipal service costs − attributable unrecovered public infrastructure costs. Keep construction spending, one-time capital projects and future projections outside this annual subtotal unless explicitly annualized using a stated schedule.
That fiscal subtotal is not the overall social cost. A water-stressed community may face significant supply or ecological risk even when the municipal budget looks healthy. A municipal utility’s capital plan can include many customers and should not be assigned entirely to a single data center without the utility’s allocation study.
Three examples of why attribution matters
- Virginia: JLARC found that data centers under existing rates were paying allocated service costs, while projecting $14–$37 monthly additional residential power-system costs by 2040 under scenarios. That is a future systemwide risk, not a currently billed facility charge. Read the legislative report.
- Santa Clara: A city staff report estimated $35.2 million of data-center-related General Fund revenues for FY 2025/26. Its more than $450 million utility infrastructure program benefits multiple customer groups and is not wholly chargeable to data centers. Read the municipal staff report.
- Australia: A national consultation proposes avoiding net infrastructure costs to communities through fair developer contributions. It is an illustrative policy framework, not evidence a specific facility already complies. Read the consultation.
A document request you can send to your local government
Request the signed development agreement and amendments; utility interconnection and rate-class terms; electric and water cost-of-service studies; environmental, water withdrawal, stormwater and air permits; the fiscal impact analysis; tax incentives and exemptions; local hiring reports; community-benefit agreements; decommissioning bonds; and annual compliance filings. Ask the agency to identify which records are public, exempt, not yet submitted, or unavailable.
When figures conflict, preserve both originals, note which agency controls the metric, identify the time period and measurement boundary, and label the disagreement instead of silently choosing the larger or more dramatic number.
Publication standard
Before claiming that a project is a net positive or net negative to a community, the record must identify the affected community, the specific project, data sources, payer/beneficiary and time horizon. If major costs or benefits remain undocumented, the right conclusion is insufficient evidence for a reliable net estimate.
Companion to The Glowing Oracle community-cost investigation. This worksheet is not a data-center ranking; its purpose is to document evidence, identify gaps, and avoid unsupported claims about any operator.
Follow This Story: See the source-linked history of AI infrastructure, electricity, cooling, water and community costs. This article contributes related reporting, not a newly verified historical milestone.

Leave a Reply